>資料と年代(再度)>quest_for_truth Ⅰ
投稿者: quest_for_truth_jp 投稿日時: 2003/01/30 21:28 投稿番号: [151752 / 177456]
>2:あなたがMSG:151691で「化学兵器爆弾六千五百個と生物兵器八千五百リットルは今日のイラク査察報告に載っている。」と言われたことを示すソース(UNMOVICの公式報告)
私が示した下記のURLは1月27日のブリスク委員長の査察報告(前回述べた「今日のイラク査察報告」)を含んでいます。
http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2003/sc7644.doc.htm
>「化学兵器爆弾六千五百個と生物兵器八千五百リットルは今日のイラク査察報告に載っている。」の内容に関しては、6,500個の化学兵器に関してはその数字すらありませんでしたし・・・
書いてありますよ。↓差し引き6500になるでしょう。
On the so-called “Air Force document”, found by an UNSCOM inspector in a safe in Iraqi Air Force Headquarters in 1998 and providing an account of the expenditures of bombs, including chemical bombs, by Iraq in the Iraq-Iran war, he was encouraged by the fact that Iraq had now provided that document to UNMOVIC. The document indicated that 13,000 chemical bombs were dropped by the Iraqi Air Force between 1983 and 1988, while Iraq had declared that 19,500 bombs were consumed during that period. Thus, there was a discrepancy on the order of about 1,000 tonnes. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, he must assume that those quantities were now unaccounted for.
>8,500リットルの生物兵器に関しては「On biological agents, he said Iraq had provided little evidence for its declared production of 8,500 litres of anthrax and no convincing evidence of its destruction, which it stated it had unilaterally done in 1991. 」との部分はあったものの、あなたの言う生物化学兵器(一般)に関するものではありませんでしたし、98年まで査察にあたっていたUNSCOMの推定(あなたの言う「認めている」?)に対する言及ではなく、91年のイラク敗戦時より一方的に(unilaterally)始められていたと言う言及です。
もう少し読み進めますと次のようにかいてあります。
On biological weapons, he recalled that Iraq had produced about 8,500 litres of anthrax, a biological warfare agent, which it stated it had unilaterally destroyed in the summer of 1991. Iraq had provided little evidence for that production and no convincing evidence for its destruction. There were strong indications that Iraq had produced more anthrax than it had declared and that at least some of that had been retained after the declared destruction date. That might still exist. Either it should be found and destroyed under UNMOVIC supervision, or convincing evidence should be produced to show that it had been destroyed in 1991. Also, Iraq had not declared a significant quantity of bacterial growth media, which had been acknowledged as imported in Iraq. The quantity of media involved would suffice to produce about 5,000 litres of concentrated anthrax, he said.
つまり、UNSCOMも推定しているのです。
私が示した下記のURLは1月27日のブリスク委員長の査察報告(前回述べた「今日のイラク査察報告」)を含んでいます。
http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2003/sc7644.doc.htm
>「化学兵器爆弾六千五百個と生物兵器八千五百リットルは今日のイラク査察報告に載っている。」の内容に関しては、6,500個の化学兵器に関してはその数字すらありませんでしたし・・・
書いてありますよ。↓差し引き6500になるでしょう。
On the so-called “Air Force document”, found by an UNSCOM inspector in a safe in Iraqi Air Force Headquarters in 1998 and providing an account of the expenditures of bombs, including chemical bombs, by Iraq in the Iraq-Iran war, he was encouraged by the fact that Iraq had now provided that document to UNMOVIC. The document indicated that 13,000 chemical bombs were dropped by the Iraqi Air Force between 1983 and 1988, while Iraq had declared that 19,500 bombs were consumed during that period. Thus, there was a discrepancy on the order of about 1,000 tonnes. In the absence of evidence to the contrary, he must assume that those quantities were now unaccounted for.
>8,500リットルの生物兵器に関しては「On biological agents, he said Iraq had provided little evidence for its declared production of 8,500 litres of anthrax and no convincing evidence of its destruction, which it stated it had unilaterally done in 1991. 」との部分はあったものの、あなたの言う生物化学兵器(一般)に関するものではありませんでしたし、98年まで査察にあたっていたUNSCOMの推定(あなたの言う「認めている」?)に対する言及ではなく、91年のイラク敗戦時より一方的に(unilaterally)始められていたと言う言及です。
もう少し読み進めますと次のようにかいてあります。
On biological weapons, he recalled that Iraq had produced about 8,500 litres of anthrax, a biological warfare agent, which it stated it had unilaterally destroyed in the summer of 1991. Iraq had provided little evidence for that production and no convincing evidence for its destruction. There were strong indications that Iraq had produced more anthrax than it had declared and that at least some of that had been retained after the declared destruction date. That might still exist. Either it should be found and destroyed under UNMOVIC supervision, or convincing evidence should be produced to show that it had been destroyed in 1991. Also, Iraq had not declared a significant quantity of bacterial growth media, which had been acknowledged as imported in Iraq. The quantity of media involved would suffice to produce about 5,000 litres of concentrated anthrax, he said.
つまり、UNSCOMも推定しているのです。
これは メッセージ 151739 (now_here_is_nowhere さん)への返信です.
固定リンク:https://yarchive.emmanuelc.dix.asia/1143582/bpjfa4lla5fa5m_1/151752.html