ケリー博士問題についてのヒュットン報告
投稿者： stwmpxqmwts 投稿日時： 2004/01/29 08:28 投稿番号： [162181 / 177456]
ケリー博士問題についてのヒュットン報告が出たらしい。
膨大な文書らしく、ＢＢＣでも数十本のレポートが出ている。
すぐには処理できないので、とりあえずけ簡略そうな結論のみ。
○ケリー博士は自殺。
○「イラクが４５分以内に生物・化学兵器を配備できる」というのは、政府側の差込というAndrew Gilligan's report はウソ。
○ＢＢＣはGilligan氏の管理に問題があった。
○ブレア報告には、Gilligan氏の主張する"sexed up" （誇張）は認められなかった。
以下省略
やはりＢＢＣのGilligan記者が一番悪いのではないだろうか？
大量破壊兵器についても、米英軍の侵攻を脅かすほどではないが、周辺諸国にとって脅威であるとケリー博士は言ってた。
それにしても、「ケリー氏のことを思うと胸が痛む」とまで書いたryuuyuuressiはなんと弔辞を書くのだろう？
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3437315.stm
以下ＢＢＣ記事の本文
Key points: The Hutton report
Here are the major points from Lord Hutton's report into events surrounding the death of weapons expert Dr David Kelly.
ON DR KELLY'S DEATH
Dr Kelly took his own life and no third party was involved
No-one involved could have contemplated that Dr Kelly would take his own life as a result of the pressures he felt
THE HUTTON REPORT
Dr Kelly was not an easy man to help or to whom to give advice
Can not be certain of factors that drove Dr Kelly to suicide
Dr Kelly probably killed himself because of extreme loss of self-esteem and would have seen himself as being publicly disgraced
Dr Kelly would have felt his job was at risk and that his life's work could be undermined
ON ANDREW GILLIGAN'S REPORT
Andrew Gilligan's report that Downing Street "probably knew" the 45-minute claim in its Iraq dossier was wrong was a grave allegation and attacked the integrity of the government and the Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC)
The 45-minute claim in the Iraq dossier was based on a report received by the intelligence services that they believed to be reliable
Whether or not that source was subsequently shown to be unreliable, the central allegation made by Andrew Gilligan in his BBC report was unfounded
The allegation that the reason the claim was not in the original draft of the dossier was because it was only from one source and the intelligence service did not believe it to be true, was also unfounded
It is not possible to reach a definite conclusion as to what Dr Kelly said to Mr Gilligan
Satisfied Dr Kelly did not say to Mr Gilligan that the government knew the 45-minute claim was wrong or that intelligence agencies did not believe it was necessarily true
ON THE BBC
Editorial system at BBC was defective in allowing Mr Gilligan's report to go to air without editors seeing a script
BBC management failed to make an examination of Mr Gilligan's notes of the interview with Dr Kelly
There was a defect in the BBC's management system relating to the way complaints were investigated
BBC governors failed to investigate Mr Gilligan's actions properly
ON THE PREPARATION OF THE DOSSIER
The Prime Minister's desire to have as compelling a dossier as possible may have subconsciously influenced the JIC to make the language of the dossier stronger than they would otherwise have done
The JIC and its chairman, John Scarlett, were concerned to ensure that the contents of the dossier were consistent with the intelligence available to the JIC
The dossier could be said to be "sexed up" if this term is taken to mean it was drafted to make the case against Saddam as strong as intelligence permitted
But in the context of Mr Gilligan's report, "sexed up" would be understood to mean the dossier was embellished with items of intelligence known or believed to be false or unreliable. This alleg
膨大な文書らしく、ＢＢＣでも数十本のレポートが出ている。
すぐには処理できないので、とりあえずけ簡略そうな結論のみ。
○ケリー博士は自殺。
○「イラクが４５分以内に生物・化学兵器を配備できる」というのは、政府側の差込というAndrew Gilligan's report はウソ。
○ＢＢＣはGilligan氏の管理に問題があった。
○ブレア報告には、Gilligan氏の主張する"sexed up" （誇張）は認められなかった。
以下省略
やはりＢＢＣのGilligan記者が一番悪いのではないだろうか？
大量破壊兵器についても、米英軍の侵攻を脅かすほどではないが、周辺諸国にとって脅威であるとケリー博士は言ってた。
それにしても、「ケリー氏のことを思うと胸が痛む」とまで書いたryuuyuuressiはなんと弔辞を書くのだろう？
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3437315.stm
以下ＢＢＣ記事の本文
Key points: The Hutton report
Here are the major points from Lord Hutton's report into events surrounding the death of weapons expert Dr David Kelly.
ON DR KELLY'S DEATH
Dr Kelly took his own life and no third party was involved
No-one involved could have contemplated that Dr Kelly would take his own life as a result of the pressures he felt
THE HUTTON REPORT
Dr Kelly was not an easy man to help or to whom to give advice
Can not be certain of factors that drove Dr Kelly to suicide
Dr Kelly probably killed himself because of extreme loss of self-esteem and would have seen himself as being publicly disgraced
Dr Kelly would have felt his job was at risk and that his life's work could be undermined
ON ANDREW GILLIGAN'S REPORT
Andrew Gilligan's report that Downing Street "probably knew" the 45-minute claim in its Iraq dossier was wrong was a grave allegation and attacked the integrity of the government and the Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC)
The 45-minute claim in the Iraq dossier was based on a report received by the intelligence services that they believed to be reliable
Whether or not that source was subsequently shown to be unreliable, the central allegation made by Andrew Gilligan in his BBC report was unfounded
The allegation that the reason the claim was not in the original draft of the dossier was because it was only from one source and the intelligence service did not believe it to be true, was also unfounded
It is not possible to reach a definite conclusion as to what Dr Kelly said to Mr Gilligan
Satisfied Dr Kelly did not say to Mr Gilligan that the government knew the 45-minute claim was wrong or that intelligence agencies did not believe it was necessarily true
ON THE BBC
Editorial system at BBC was defective in allowing Mr Gilligan's report to go to air without editors seeing a script
BBC management failed to make an examination of Mr Gilligan's notes of the interview with Dr Kelly
There was a defect in the BBC's management system relating to the way complaints were investigated
BBC governors failed to investigate Mr Gilligan's actions properly
ON THE PREPARATION OF THE DOSSIER
The Prime Minister's desire to have as compelling a dossier as possible may have subconsciously influenced the JIC to make the language of the dossier stronger than they would otherwise have done
The JIC and its chairman, John Scarlett, were concerned to ensure that the contents of the dossier were consistent with the intelligence available to the JIC
The dossier could be said to be "sexed up" if this term is taken to mean it was drafted to make the case against Saddam as strong as intelligence permitted
But in the context of Mr Gilligan's report, "sexed up" would be understood to mean the dossier was embellished with items of intelligence known or believed to be false or unreliable. This alleg
これは メッセージ 1 (messages_admin さん)への返信です．
固定リンク：https://yarchive.emmanuelc.dix.asia/1143582/bpjfa4lla5fa5m_1/162181.html